UK High Court lets self-represented litigants recover the cost of an AI legal research tool
The High Court of England and Wales has allowed two people who represented themselves in court to recover the £1,488 cost of an AI legal research subscription, ruling that it counts as a disbursement reasonably incurred for the litigation.
Linda Foster and Richard Hitchens, who successfully appealed a possession order over their flat in Foster & Hitchens v Wargrave on Thames Housing Association Ltd, used the tool to find authorities, research the law and prepare submissions, borrowing money to pay for it. Mr Justice Sweeting rejected their argument that the subscription was a payment for "legal services", saying it gave access to software they used themselves, comparable to a legal database or practitioner text, and did not involve advice from a lawyer.
But he found the cost recoverable as a specific litigation support expense rather than general overhead, and said the use of AI required no special rule. "The technology itself neither renders the expenditure automatically recoverable nor automatically irrecoverable," he said, adding that it would be "an odd outcome" if lawyers could use their AI tools in litigation while litigants in person were in effect barred from similar ones, according to Local Government Lawyer.
The judgment stresses the limits of the decision. The appellants are pensioners in their 70s living in social housing who could not get legal aid or afford advice, and they paid for a subscription to a sector-specific AI legal agent rather than a general or free chatbot. The judge found the tool made a real contribution to their careful and ultimately successful submissions. He said the cost of AI-assisted support is not automatically recoverable, and warned that using AI "to generate prolix and unhelpful material" is likely to see costs disallowed. "The technology may be new, but the principles governing recoverability are not," he wrote.
We hope you enjoyed this article
Consider subscribing to one of our newsletters like Legal AI Weekly, AI Policy Brief or Daily AI Brief.
Also, consider following us on social media:
More from Legal AI
Nov 19 BDO signs a global agreement to roll out Legora's legal AI Nov 18 OpenAI opens Astra for Law to all ChatGPT Enterprise customers Nov 18 Litera says AI tripled engineer output as it names Greg Ingino chief technology and AI officer Nov 18 Wimbledon names Harvey its first official legal AI partner from 2027 Nov 18 SK Group rolls out Harvey's legal AI across more than 20 affiliatesMore from Regulation
Nov 19 Arizona opens criminal investigation into OpenAI over what it calls rogue AI agents in banks Nov 18 Nvidia scandal complicates US-China AI talks ahead of Trump-Xi meeting, Wired reports Nov 18 Beijing AI safety group Concordia AI briefed OpenAI staff on China's approach to AI risk Nov 18 EU sets rules for AI regulatory sandboxes, with free access for start-ups Nov 18 San José pauses data centre approvals while it writes new standardsLegal AI Weekly
The source for the Legal AI software news, analysis, emerging applications: contract review, e-discovery, research.
Market report
2025 Generative AI in Professional Services Report
Thomson Reuters
This report by Thomson Reuters explores the integration and impact of generative AI technologies, such as ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot, within the professional services sector. It highlights the growing adoption of GenAI tools across industries like legal, tax, accounting, and government, and discusses the challenges and opportunities these technologies present. The report also examines professionals' perceptions of GenAI and the need for strategic integration to maximize its value.
Read moreYou may also like
Delaware Chancery Court fines lawyer $2,500 over AI-fabricated quotations in a brief
Law Society Says Lawyers Cannot Transfer Responsibility to AI
Relativity and IDC study: AI has not changed hiring for most legal professionals
Justice Department uses AI detector Pangram to challenge defense filings in voter fraud case
Report says UK Home Office is expanding AI use in immigration decisions with little transparency
Daily AI Brief: the AI news that matters, in your inbox.